About Us


Your Trusted Insurance Partner

Locally Inspired Insurance Since 1989


We’re Insurance Outfitters®—and yes, that’s our real name. We chose it because we wanted something different, something true to our adventurous spirit and community-first values.



Since opening our doors in 1989, we’ve remained an independent agency focused on one thing: helping our neighbors protect what matters with honest advice and customized coverage.

Our Philosophy

We don’t believe in “selling insurance.” We believe in outfitting people with what they actually need—and nothing they don’t.



That means taking the time to explain your options. It means earning your trust, year after year. It means showing up when you call, and following through when you need us.

Meet the People Behind the Policies


Tom Maiden and the Insurance Outfitters® team are proud locals who love where they live—and love helping people live with peace of mind.


Decades of experience, right here in the Mid-Atlantic

Strong ties with local lenders, small businesses, and community groups

Every team member is trained to put people first, not policies

scott@cmigllc.com

A pair of black quotation marks on a white background.
We’re not here to be flashy. We’re here to be real. That’s how we’ve earned every five-star review—and that’s how we’ll earn your trust, too.

Meet Our Interns


A woman in a suit and white shirt smiles for the camera

Lena Camilletti

Pioneer
A woman with short hair is wearing a white shirt and smiling for the camera.

Thube Ncube

Pioneer
A woman with braids is wearing a white shirt and smiling

Fatoumata (Fatim) Plea

Pioneer

Our Office

Our uniquely octagon-shaped office building sits right here in Shepherdstown. Soon it’ll be freshly painted and filled with blooming zinnias—but it’s always been filled with care.



Stop by, give us a call, or send a text to (304) 876–0000. We’re happy to help however we can.

Let's Connect

Get in touch with us today!

Our team is ready to assist you with all your insurance needs. Reach out now to start the conversation!